Clare and Aidan are high school sweethearts who are about to head off to college. Though they care for [and maybe even love] each other, they aren’t sure whether they should try to stay together after they move 3000 miles apart — with Clare attending Dartmouth and Aidan attending UCLA. Starting college and learning to live away from their homes and best friends will be difficult enough, but trying to maintain a relationship without sacrificing the authentic college experience seems impossible… At least, to Clare it does. She is bound and determined to spend their last night in town revisiting all the places that had significance in their relationship so that they can say goodbye with enough closure to move on. Aidan still isn’t sure he’s willing to give up on their relationship. But will one last night provide him with enough time to change her mind?
Heartbreaking at times, but with plenty of moments of levity, this book is a roller coaster of emotions. Though I enjoyed Smith’s other books — The Geography of You and Me and This is What Happy Looks Like — I found that they were a little bit of a stretch. This story is a much more realistic scenario and I think it will likely resonate with more readers. If you’re unfamiliar with Smith’s books but enjoyed romances by Sarah Dessen and Jenny Han, you should definitely check out Hello, Goodbye, and Everything in Between.